Which Condition Must Be Present to Establish Medical Malpractice?

April 17, 2024

Medical malpractice remains a critical concern in the healthcare sector, highlighting significant failures that compromise patient safety and care. This form of professional negligence involves medical practitioners—from doctors and nurses to therapists and other healthcare providers—failing to meet the established standards of care, thereby causing harm to patients. 

Which Condition Must Be Present to Establish Malpractice

The consequences of such failures are not only severe for the affected individuals but also raise broader questions about trust and accountability in medical professions. Understanding the fundamental condition necessary for establishing medical malpractice is essential for both healthcare professionals seeking to uphold their duties and patients advocating for their rights. 

The Essential Condition: Breach of Duty

In the realm of medical malpractice, the breach of a professional duty of care forms the cornerstone of any claim. This duty is a legal obligation imposed on healthcare providers to adhere to a standard of reasonable care while performing any acts that could foreseeably harm patients. Here is how this duty plays out in practice and what constitutes a breach:

Definition of Duty of Care

A ‘duty of care’ in medicine means that healthcare providers must act as competent professionals would under similar circumstances. This standard is not static; it evolves with advances in medical science and changes in health care practices. Essentially, the duty encompasses everything from making diagnoses to prescribing medication and conducting surgical procedures.

How a Breach Occurs

A breach of this duty occurs when a healthcare provider fails to meet the expected standard of care, and this failure is demonstrable. Examples of such breaches include:

  • Misdiagnosis or Delayed Diagnosis: Failing to diagnose a condition, or significantly delaying a diagnosis, thereby worsening the patient’s health outcome.
  • Surgical Errors: Mistakes made during surgery, such as operating on the wrong site or leaving surgical instruments inside the patient.
  • Improper Treatment: Administering treatment that is inappropriate for the patient’s condition or failing to consider available medical alternatives.
  • Medication Errors: Prescribing or administering the wrong medication or incorrect dosage.

Proving a Breach of Duty

To establish that a breach of duty occurred, it must be shown that a prudent healthcare provider in the same field, under similar circumstances, would have acted differently. This often requires expert testimony to establish what the standard of care is and how the defendant deviated from this standard.

Other Necessary Elements for a Malpractice Claim

While the breach of duty is a crucial component, there are additional elements that must be present to successfully prove a medical malpractice case. These elements include causation and damages, which together with the breach of duty, form the triad necessary to establish malpractice.

Proving Causation

Causation in medical malpractice involves demonstrating that the breach of duty directly caused the patient’s harm. This means linking the healthcare provider’s deviation from the standard of care to the injury or worsening condition of the patient. Establishing causation typically requires:

  • Medical Expertise: Testimony from medical experts who can explain how the provider’s actions or inactions led directly to the patient’s harm.
  • Patient Records: Comprehensive review of the patient’s medical records before and after the incident to trace the sequence of events and identify the exact cause of harm.

Demonstrating Damages

The final element in a malpractice claim is proving that the patient suffered actual damages due to the breach. These damages can be physical, emotional, or financial, including:

  • Physical Suffering: This might include pain and suffering due to the injury, a deterioration in health, or the need for additional medical treatment.
  • Financial Losses: These are often quantifiable and include medical bills for corrective treatment, lost wages if the patient was unable to work, and sometimes future lost earnings.
  • Emotional Distress: Emotional and psychological damages are also considered, especially in cases where the patient’s quality of life has been significantly impacted.

Establishing these damages is essential, as they directly influence the compensation the plaintiff may receive. Without clear evidence of damages, a malpractice claim cannot succeed, regardless of the presence of a breach and causation.

Contact Matzus Law, LLC Today

Establishing a medical malpractice claim involves more than just identifying an error made by a healthcare provider; it requires proving a specific set of legal elements. Understanding these elements is crucial for both patients who believe they have been wronged and medical professionals seeking to uphold the highest standards of care.

Medical malpractice claims are complex and require a nuanced understanding of both medical and legal principles. For patients, these claims offer a pathway to compensation for wrongful injuries, while for healthcare providers, they underscore the importance of adherence to professional standards to avoid legal repercussions. Whether you are a medical professional or a patient, staying informed about these elements can help navigate the challenges of medical malpractice cases more effectively.  Contact Matzus Law, LLC today for a free, no-obligation consultation, or call us at (412) 206-5300 to talk with our legal team to learn more about your options in your case.  


He’s Brilliant.
Jason Matzus is a Lawyer —
You Thank God is on Your Side.



Case Results

Medical Malpractice
Confidential Settlement
Birth Injury
Confidential Settlement
Surgical Error
Confidential Settlement